---
title: Boy Crushed by Oil Burner, Sues his Parents
description: Boy Crushed by Oil Burner, Sues his Parents
---

[Skip to content](https://counselfinancial.com/litigation-counsellor/boy-crushed-by-oil-burner-sues-his-parents/#main-content)

[![Brandmark](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/2024%20Website/Brand%20Logos/Brandmark.svg "Brandmark")](https://counselfinancial.com/)

[![Counsel Financial](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/2024%20Website/Brand%20Logos/Text-Logo.svg "Counsel Financial")](https://counselfinancial.com/)

- [Law Firms](https://counselfinancial.com/law-firms)
- [Capital Providers](https://counselfinancial.com/captial-providers)
- About Us
  
  Show submenu for About Us ![](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Counsel-Financial-Theme/images/icons/arrow-down.svg) 
  
    - [Loan Process](https://counselfinancial.com/about/loan-process)
    - [Our Team](https://counselfinancial.com/about/our-team)
    - [Lending Philosophy](https://counselfinancial.com/about/lending-philosophy)
    - [Contact](https://counselfinancial.com/contact)
- Resources
  
  Show submenu for Resources ![](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Counsel-Financial-Theme/images/icons/arrow-down.svg) 
  
    - [Blog](https://counselfinancial.com/blog)
    - [Case Studies](https://counselfinancial.com/case-studies)

- [Law Firms](https://counselfinancial.com/law-firms)
- [Capital Providers](https://counselfinancial.com/captial-providers)
- About Us
  
  Show submenu for About Us ![](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Counsel-Financial-Theme/images/icons/arrow-down.svg) 
  
    - [Loan Process](https://counselfinancial.com/about/loan-process)
    - [Our Team](https://counselfinancial.com/about/our-team)
    - [Lending Philosophy](https://counselfinancial.com/about/lending-philosophy)
    - [Contact](https://counselfinancial.com/contact)
- Resources
  
  Show submenu for Resources ![](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Counsel-Financial-Theme/images/icons/arrow-down.svg) 
  
    - [Blog](https://counselfinancial.com/blog)
    - [Case Studies](https://counselfinancial.com/case-studies)

[Request a Meeting ![](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Counsel-Financial-Theme/images/icons/button-arrow-blue.svg)](https://counselfinancial.com/request-a-meeting)

[Contact ![](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Counsel-Financial-Theme/images/icons/button-arrow-blue.svg)](https://counselfinancial.com/contact)

[Litigation Counsellor](https://counselfinancial.com/litigation-counsellor/topic/litigation_counsellor)

# Boy Crushed by Oil Burner, Sues his Parents

By: Counsel Financial

 June 26, 2011

Plaintiff was moving an oil burner down a set of stairs in his home. While moving the oil burner, the stairs collapsed beneath him causing the oil burner to fall onto him. Plaintiff sued his parents, alleging negligent maintenance of the premises, and that their negligence created a dangerous condition. Defendant-parents' insurer disclaimed coverage, and the defendants failed to answer the complaint. A default judgment was entered, and the court was left to determine damages.

**VERDICT: $1,170,000**

James MacWhinnie v. Herbert MacWhinnie and Linda MacWhinnie, Case No. 15063/10 (Suffolk County, NY, Hon. John J.J. Jones Jr., March 30, 2011).

[Litigation Counsellor](https://counselfinancial.com/litigation-counsellor/topic/litigation_counsellor)

## Recent Posts

### [Bicyclist Dragged by Bus After Being Knocked Off Bike by Cab Learn More ![](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Counsel-Financial-Theme/images/theme-assets/link-graphic-green.svg)](https://counselfinancial.com/litigation-counsellor/bicyclist-dragged-by-bus-after-being-knocked-off-bike-by-cab/)

### [![IMG_5595](https://counselfinancial.com/hs-fs/hubfs/blog-files/Images/Royalty%20Free%20/IMG_5595.jpg?width=352&name=IMG_5595.jpg) Counsel Financial Founder and Director Goes "Bald for BIG Bucks" Learn More ![](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Counsel-Financial-Theme/images/theme-assets/link-graphic-green.svg)](https://counselfinancial.com/litigation-counsellor/counsel-financial-founder-and-director-goes-bald-for-big-bucks)

### [![computer-1185637_960_720](https://counselfinancial.com/hs-fs/hubfs/blog-files/Images/Royalty%20Free%20/computer-1185637_960_720.jpg?width=352&name=computer-1185637_960_720.jpg) Burt’s Bees Faces Allegations over Failure to Comply with ADA Learn More ![](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Counsel-Financial-Theme/images/theme-assets/link-graphic-green.svg)](https://counselfinancial.com/litigation-counsellor/burts-bees-faces-allegations-over-failure-to-comply-with-ada)

![Counsel Financial](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/2024%20Website/Brand%20Logos/Full-Logo-Stacked.svg) ![minimal-brandmark](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/2024%20Website/Brand%20Logos/minimal-brandmark.svg)

- [![location](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/2024%20Website/Icons/location.svg) 500 Pearl St., 
 Suite 820
 Buffalo, NY 14202](https://maps.app.goo.gl/xQVgoc7dvspNBDsy6)
- [![phone](https://counselfinancial.com/hubfs/2024%20Website/Icons/phone.svg) (716) 568–0070](tel:+17165680070)

Law Firms

- [Law Firm Loans](https://counselfinancial.com/law-firms)

Capital Providers

- [Capital Solutions](https://counselfinancial.com/captial-providers)

About Us

- [Loan Process](https://counselfinancial.com/about/loan-process)
- [Our Team](https://counselfinancial.com/about/our-team)
- [Lending Philosophy](https://counselfinancial.com/about/lending-philosophy)
- [Contact](https://counselfinancial.com/contact)

Resources

- [Case Studies](https://counselfinancial.com/case-studies)
- [Blog](https://counselfinancial.com/blog)

---

© 2026 Counsel Financial  |  [Privacy Policy](https://counselfinancial.com/privacy-policy)  |  [Terms](https://counselfinancial.com/terms-and-conditions-of-use)  |  [Cookie Policy](https://counselfinancial.com/cookie-policy)

[Follow us on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/company/counsel-financial-services/)